James Murray
Judas
Jeremy Guskin
Jesus
Ronney Ascher
Manuel Hossenfeffer Rodriguez
Marti Cooney
Mrs. Baker / Hoagie Woman
Laurence Frommer
Mr. Baker
Elizabeth Wood
Mary / Disgusted Angel
David Skigen
Joseph
Sal Vulcano
Lawn Mower Boy / Extra
Matthew Glass
Larry
Hank Poje
James Peterson / God / Smitty
Jonah Zeiger
Vinny (as Jonah Zieger)
Kelley Rae O'Donnell
Play Angel
David Hubbell
Herbie Falafen
James P. Murray
George
