Jeremy Rishe
Marty Kidner
Logan Taylor
Young Marty
Ray Reynolds
Mick
Doug Farrell
The Candyman
Dale E. Turner
Carl
Brian Dale Brown
Jonah
Julius Callahan
Kierst
Mark Beltzman
Sweet Tooth
Maxx Maulion
Gary
Marc Geller
Marshmallow Man
Alex Louis
Childhood Friend
Frankie Petrosino
Little Boy
Nico Petrosino
Young Marty's friend / Kit Kat Kid
Jesse VanDerveer
Ding Dong Kid
