Andy Richter
Himself
Lauren Lapkus
Andy's Wife
Eddie Pepitone
Santa Claus
Jon Daly
Sappity Tappity
Mike Cassady
Andy's Uncle
Allan McLeod
Talking Gift
Seth Morris
Little Bobby Ducca
Matt Besser
Bjork
Betsy Sodaro
Andy's Mom
Eric Hoffman
Red Sandwich
Diona Reasonover
Andy's Sister
Michael Blaiklock
Andy's Son
Ego Nwodim
Michelle Obama
